Review Ugly Pizza - Caringbah

Always great pizza at Ugly's! We ate in for dinner and ordered the Peri Peri Chicken, Triple P, Chilli Prawn, Ugly Special and kids ham and cheese. It was all delicious. We ate inside Huxleys and also ordered the buffalo wings. The staff kindly offered us pizza boxes for our left overs 😊 A great restaurant for the family and groups. The bartender was awesome. Looking up where a beer was brewed and sold that we liked. 2 x 👍

Amazing food but even better customer service thank you Emma for being so helpful and quick to fix my order Food and customer services is 10/10

The forget about it pizza has been a fave for a long time now, can't go wrong! The Mac and cheese is also incredible though was a little dissapointed they forgot the sauces for our wings and the dessert dough boys- cause they are too dry without that salted caramel!

Is still alright, but definitely had better elsewhere. Pizzas used to be much better, and i'm not sure if it's because we got takeaway or what but it wasn't nearly as good as a couple of years ago. Even a year ago it was much better. Could be because a change of hand? Not sure, but definitely a shadow of its former glory. The base was not as nice tasting and overall the way everything on the pizza meshed together was subpar, defs no longer worth the somewhat premium price. Probably won't be ordering here again, but if it gets better then might reconsider it. Just my two cents :)

2nd time I've had pizza here and I'm still yet to be impressed. The deal they sent out for 2 for 25 is great it's just the taste of the pizza is very boring. I got the Arabian night and the description sounds lovely but it was so bland. The lamb minced balls tasted as if there was no seasoning at all and the other elements were visible but couldn't taste them at all. Maybe the ingredients were old if youre looking for great pizza in the shire look at italian food affair they have never disappointed me.

Great pizzas. Great staff.

Hands down, No contest and without question "The Best" pizza in The Shire!!!!! The staff are fantastic, very friendly and welcoming!!! If you want truly great pizza with outstanding value then get yourself and your family or friends to Ugly Pizza in Caringbah and i guarantee that you won't be disappointed!

Visited for the first time and we had a great meal. Large pizza was enough to share between two adults, with the dough balls and two kids pizzas all proving good value for a family of four (tip: sign up for a feros card to get money off your bill). No reservations so you'll take your chances with getting a table but we were there at 5pm on a Friday and didn't have any problems

Disclaimer *not my photo*.... I was drunk and though I took pictures but obviously didn't 🤔<br/><br/>Pizza wasn't bad at all and had the nice crisp thin base with a good amount of topping to dough ratio .<br/><br/>I wouldn't say it would be my go to Pizzeria but if your in the area you wouldn't go wrong either

Nothing much to rave about here sadly. We shared 5 pizzas between us. The pizza crust itself was the highlight, super crispy towards the outside. However the toppings were a little disappointing. Maybe I have a preference for traditional Italian style Pizza but the majority of pizza lacked good fresh flavour - rather made you feel sick at how fatty it was. The redeeming pizza was one with slow cooked lamb, feta, tomato and a yoghurt sauce. That was outstanding.

Loved the pizza here! It's a cool American theme and attached to a secret American bar too! How cool!<br/> We sat at the pizza bar and watched them make the pizza! Very fascinating and impressed how they remember all the recipes! Definitely drooling by the time our pizza came steaming hot out of the oven 🔥

Not sure what "New York style" pizza means but it was delicious. The pizzas has a thin, charred base with clean tasting toppings. The EPIC supreme of chicken, pepperoni, olives, capsicum, onions, mushrooms & pineapple was really flavoursome & not heavy and the El Monterrey was so delicious with that chilli pulled beef in chipotle adobo, pico de gallo, serrano peppers & sour cream. It was sweet, salty & spicy all at the same time. Yum for a takeaway pizza!

Great pizza joint with yummy pizzas and lovely service. We got the pumpkin and feta arancini and the California pizza and they were both really delicious 👌🏻

How disappointing! After the marketing blitz I was expecting much more. The base was good but many of the ingredients (mushrooms etc) were the soggy jar variety rather than fresh. I had the epic supreme.

I ordered home delivery last night from Ugly Pizza Caringbah. I only live around the corner from the restaurant (yes I am lazy!!). I gave my address when I ordered only to have the driver call me about 40 minutes later telling me he couldn't find my address. He said he had a GPS (he couldn't have as my address comes up on GPS). I worked out where he was and gave him more directions. 10 minutes later he rings me back again and says he can't find my place what should I do?? (are you serious??). Again I worked out he was a couple of blocks from my place and gave him more directions. He asked if I could meet him where he was. I said what was the point of paying a $3 delivery charge if I have to pick up the pizza myself. I then called the restaurant who said they would call the driver. 20 minutes later he arrived with cold pizza. And yes everyone out there I should have just ordered take away instead!