Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Carnegie
4 restaurant menus in Australia, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
1 2 1 2 Pineapple Chicken and Tandoori Chicken Pizza
Capricciosa Pizza
Pasta
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Best pizza in Carnegie for sure.Ordered a small Hawaiian for $12. Good quality ham and I think they include fresh, sweet pineapple also. Crust..."
Princeofharts
"Love ordering takeaway from this place! The pizzas and pastas are so..."
Alvin Lee
"Pizza the way it should be. Family owned and generous pizza toppings and classic selections, none of this fancy gourmet crazy toppings. Bonus points..."
Hungry Little Dinosaur
"The absolutely best pizza you can get in Carnegie. Lots of fantastic options on the menu and a full bar. The people are so friendly as..."
Raakhee Kaura
"Great old fashion pizza place, the type that gets the mouth watering from the amazing smell as you walk down the street. Great toppings, perfect..."
Michelle Coysh Osmers
"3.5When the mercury hits 40°C and beyond, there’s no reason to slave over a hot stove in the kitchen so it was a pizza night for us via..."
Jojo Armani
"My New Regular Spot!This place does amazing pizza. The dough is so light and soft, decent toppings, delicious sauces. Can't fault the pizza..."
Matthew Nulty
"Friendly and accommodating service, no fuss restaurant with fantastic pizza! The pizza base was soft but crisp (not chewy) and toppings were generous..."
Smitten Kitten
"Best pizza in Carnegie. Reasonable price. Full of toppings and also free delivery in Carnegie as well. We’ve been regular customers since when we..."
Erin
"Have been coming to this family run business for the past 25 years! Lovely staff. This pizza is amazing! I drive from South Yarra for it! Absolutely..."
Bridget
"The best garlic pizza and tortellini carbonara. The owner is a hard worker and always polite and has a smile. This place seems like an institution in..."
The Reviewer
"Has been there forever, and with good reason. Gabriella is a bit of an institution. Many have come and gone in the area, but Gabriella keeps on..."
The Dear Luncher
"Beware!! Their pizzas are huge with lots of toppings. Have it here or take it away but make sure you have enough space in your tummy or call frenz...."
Priyanka
"My favourite pizza in Carnegie !! Definitely try the BBQ chicken pizza !!! Always fresh and the toppings are always plenty! The staff are also very..."
Diana Dee
"Golden Pizza 👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻Me and my sister order it for delivered. It takes around half an hour. However its really worth it. :)..."
Oodreiilittlepotato
"Amazing and tasty pizza with excellent coffee. Must visit. Best pizza place on the street. #pizza #carnegie #melbourne will definitely come back..."
Swapnil Ruhela
"As far as independent pizza joints go, this is one of the better places. The base had a decent thickness and is stays crispy. These guys aren't..."
Flying Forward
"Satisfied my Parma cravings!!! Awesome flavours. Just a bit too much breadcrumb coating and needed more vegetables. It was a bit soggy from having it..."
Wenjin.thio
"Packed with toppings and always cooked perfectly. One of the best pizza places for the price! Its no wonder Its still going strong after..."
Jarrad
"We are Carnegie locals and we love this pizza place, we've tried all the pizza places and the pizzas at Gabriella's are just really tasty. Exactly..."
Zoe
"Good old fashioned Pizza with generous toppings and a delicious base. Always packed with people of all ages eating in to enjoy a meal in. My Go-To..."
Thomas
"Great pizzas here, love the chicken avocado. Always consistently tasty, and the service is great too. Plenty of flavour and heaps of..."
Eating Food Things
"Been going here for 15 years and still the best pizza around! My partner is gluten free and rates it the best gluten free pizza he has had ever!..."
Emma Skewes
"Not sure why the reviews here are so bad. We haven't had tried the other pizza shops in Carnegie but we don't want to because we are so happy with..."
Yolanda Pantelios
"If you're after an old school pizza (before the take over of gourmet) order from here. Haven't tried the gourmet range but Love the traditional..."
Ilovenoodies
"Not a bad pizza pretty pricey but overall above average looking for a great place in Carnegie area and tried most so far. Gabs is not the best but..."
Jemd619
"Always great pizza. Great crust and base. Great toppings and great shop. Always walk out of here full and happy. Basta dire la ragazza a perdere..."
Anthony Reale
"The very best authentic pizza I've tried in a long time! Very fresh ingredients and fast delivery service. Definitely worth a try considering how..."
Natalie
"This place is still my all time favourite pizza joint in Melbourne. I've been having Gabriella pizzas since I was a kid and I still love their..."
Ash
"Gabriella Pizza used to be my local and is definitely consistently yummy and their Aussie pizza is by far the best I have tasted. I think their..."
Gdkf
"Thanks Gabriella's. We've been heading down to Gabriella's for years. We'll continue to. Solid pizza, excellent people, genuine setting - you don't..."
JenBen
"Best pizza in town. Gotta love the pizza i remember going there as a kid great memories not to forget the atmosphere and Sam's new specials all the..."
Raydan T
"Thank you Gabriella's!!. Pizza arrived promptly. Opened the box and noticed they had an extra piece of ribbed cardboard that the pizza sat on top of..."
Katy
"Love this place !!!. Love love love ! Generous toppings on the pizza.....very tasty ! Also love their pastas !!Reasonable pricing for..."
Dreammaker
"Love the Satay chicken..."
Luke
"Very nice pizza! And great staff too. Had a great night with my family. Coming back for..."
Katherine Potter
"Best Pizza in a 20km Radius. Gabriella Pizza is an institution in Koornang Road Carnegie. Don't be put off by the decor, it hasn't changed since they..."
What Mia Thought
"I have lived in Carnegie for 19 years and I am a die hard lover of Gabriella's, Herbs and Crust have nothing on this family run pizzeria, cheese is..."
Bilbo
"Large Mexicana please. I came to Gabriellas Pizza as it had received a majority of good reviews on Urbanspoon. I was not disappointed, as some..."
James C
"Gabriella's is a huge part of the Carnegie neighbourhood, has been for decades. Although I normally take away (pepperoni special always!) you often..."
Hula Jarmusch
"Good traditional Melbourne style pizza!. Having lived interstate/overseas, I really missed a good old Melbourne pizza! Imagine my disappointment..."
Rallo
"I rate their pizza's an 8/10 at least, and their chicken parma's are also good.I very much recommend this pizza..."
Mike M.
"The best pizza in town! They have an slogan at the door saying we are not the only but we are the best , and that's absolutely true!!! Pizzas are..."
Virginia
"Though I'm new to this area, I've been eyeing this pizza/pasta place for a while now, and I'm glad I visited when I did! The place is better than..."
Thurazin
"I've been eating at gabriella's for more than 20 years and there's a reason why it's still around. Great pizza with loads of garlic and great..."
Andrew B
"The best pizza's in Melbourne. I've been ordering home delivery from Gabriella's Pizza once or twice a week from 2002 - 2010 when I was in their..."
WeDineOutFrequently
"Tasty pizza!. Good pizza, friendly service. Felt like a time warp in the shop with the decor but I liked it, family business doing what they do best..."
Pousie
"Best pizza I have ever had in my life Sam your the Man I'm here every dad and always will be. For the best BBQ chicken it's..."
Saf Hak
"Classic Pizza!. Lots of toppings, very tasty pizza. If you want something traditional other than Crust all the time (like..."
TrentR
"We have been coming to Gabriellas for years and will continue to do so because Sam makes the best pizzas in the..."
Graeme Callen
"Eating in is always good at Gabriella's. Pizza's are excellent, pasta is good, and parma wont leave you hungry. I would highly recommend for a value..."
Markc
"Really is nice pizza, fresh, well topped, definitely one of the better pizzas in..."
The Hon. Rev. Pudmeister Esq.
"Best pizzas. I'm not much of an eater of pizza, but when I do I choose Gabriellas because they are always consistent in making a top pizza. They may..."
Arthurguru
"Best pizza place in Carnegie.
Had the capricciosa and sams special. Both pizzas had great toppings with good crust.
I recommend the..."
Keven Luan
"We order from Gabriella once a week and they never let us down. Sometimes the wait time is longer than usual but the pizza always tastes delicious!..."
Liam Beaton
"Frequent flyers for pizza and always wonderful! Tonight, for the second time, I’ve just ordered a spicy chicken pasta (that doesn’t actually..."
Nichola Briggs
"We had our first visit to Gabriella Pizza tonight, and took home the BEST pizza ever.
To the young lady from behind the counter who jumped around to..."
Neil Johnson
"The pizza was quite good and I was surprised at how good the chips were.
I didn't expect there to be herbs ext on them.
They went down very..."
James Parker
"Met the owner Sam over 30 years ago and the pizza is just as good as it was back then and is still now. It is the best in..."
"Staff need to learn to smile and talk with customer. Though food wise it is good. The toppings are good and whole pizza is covered with it unlike few..."
Pratik Sheth
"Best part is that it's open till late around Caulfield and Malvern. Amazing woodfire pizza they have. Recommendations for Toscano chicken. Crispy,..."
Aayush Kapoor
"Always been to this place and loved the food on offer. Wonderful service who are patient and the deals on offer are just worth every penny. Would..."
Bijith Balakrishnan
"Not sure where these bad reviews are coming from. Exceptionally polite staff, Great consistently fresh pizza with an awesome base and they customise..."
Arjun Ravi
"Absolutely love Herbs! My partner and I are loyal customers! The pizza is delish, tasty bases with fresh ingredients. Ontop of that they have melt in..."
Sammi
"where are these bad reviews coming from... great seafood pizza... had it a few times and been excellent each time. also the Moroccan lamb is worth..."
Ian Bruce
"Tried out their margherita pizza. The pizza is just to die for. I mean from the amazing charred thin crust to their sweet tomatoes in it... Its..."
Sompa Goswami
"we are new to Carnegie and we tried other places but Herbs is the best.It was great pizza and pasta, full of flavours and Customer Service also..."
Mark English
"We loved Pizza from Herbs and the Customer Service was So friendly. you should try.Toppings were so fresh. I rate The Best Pizza in Carnegie..."
Mark
"Sooo good Pizza and Pasta Strogly recommend. Best pizza ever had. base was amazing aswell as the pasta. we are so happy to have such a nice pizza..."
Smith
"I went there on Thursday night when other takeaway shops closed and had magarita and a pasta oh they were so good besides, they were way better..."
Jim
"The pasta and the pizza, both are outstanding. And to top it all, friendly staff and great delivery time. One of the best Margherita I have had in..."
Raakhee Kaura
"Sad to see all the negative reviews. I absolutely love the wood fire pizzas made here. Everything cooked in store and the friendliest service...."
Andrew Stedall
"This is the place we consistently choose to order takeaway pizza from. The gourmet options are great, and different from your usual pizza options...."
Keally Nankervis
"Very nice pizza and customer service. It was so good pizza hard to find a good pizza like thishighly..."
Michael
"The best food and service all round!. Iv been to a few pizza places over the years but then came across herbs, they are by far the best place in..."
Misty
"Delicious pizza, highly..."
Paul McIntosh
"Honestly it is the best pizza you will taste in melbourne. I have tried quite a few places and this by far was the best . Do not understand why some..."
Sonam
"Fantastic Pizza, undeserved negative feedback. I am a big fan of Herbs Pizza and have been going there for over a year. Hands down it is the best..."
Tastebuds
"Best Pizza. Yummmm They have the best thin and crispy pizza, fresh ingredients and the pastas soooo..."
Layana2006
"Beautiful pizza. Drove by this place several times to only recently take an order. Dough made every day, fresh ingredients and free delivery. Very..."
Stephen Mallett
"Real Italian Pizza is in Carnegie. A great taste of Italia! The guys behind the pizza bar are actually from Naples. Had a chat with them an found out..."
Ron Shoshan
"Tasty woodfired pizzas. My wife ordered a seafood pizza and a Mediterranean chicken pizza and I was pleasantly surprised that they actually used..."
Grant.h
"Friendly service and relatively quick delivery. The best part was the pizza was flawless. Ask for the spinach delight or the mediterranean chicken..."
"Great staff services and very easy to order food. Wide variety of choices on the menu and lots to choose from. The shop is clean and menu is simple..."
Livinia Sheridan
"My favorite crust chain and pizza chain is this Crust Carnegie branch! Their pesto chicken is the most delicious pizza of all chains.
Great friendly..."
Nana L
"Best pizza i’ve ever had, and amazing customer..."
J B
"I am a regular customer with Carnegie Crust. We mostly order veg supreme with gluten free base - this is one of the best pizzas I have had esp in the..."
Priya Negi
"Very happy with the service, employee over the phone was very patient and cheerful. Pizza was good quality and made on time, still hot when I..."
"Well Done to our local favourite. I have been ordering dinner from Basilico about 2-3 times a week since COVID pandemic that closed their dine in..."
Katherine Long
"Went down to Carnegie on Wednesday night as we know Basilico has $15 pizza night on Wednesday nights. We have dined here a few times but tonight they..."
Max Berry
"I can never commence a meal with some entrees, and what amazing entrees they were. Delicious antipasto, meatballs and bread.. you really can’t got..."
EatsOfMelbourneAus
"We love this place and their gourmet woodfired pizza! 🍕💥😍🙌Remix of the classic with a yummy twist.🍕🙌Selected mixed seafoods -..."
HUNGRYMATE
"My daughter love pasta of basilico.Good overall experience with Basilico all the time. Consistent food quality and test.Good location.Pre booking is..."
Live For Food
"We had an amazing meal here. The staff went to a special effort for our anniversary with a special desert. Great food, friendly staff and great..."
Kayanne Allan
"Great Italian food. The usual array of dishes. Wholesome and relatively inexpensive. Perfect for family or casual dining. Always busy so best to book..."
Dean.sinclair
"After looking at the reviews, we were hesitant to book here and that was about 6 months ago. Since then, We have become regulars and it’s now a..."
Frankie Walsh
"A hard earned hunger is best remedied by pizza, and the best cold pizza is Basilico, Carnegie Basilico. Well, not really the best but pretty decent...."
The Dear Luncher
"The guys at Basilico looked after my partner and I whilst we wined and dined on a chilly weeknight - all of the food was SO fresh and..."
Lilly Callaghan
"I'm quite surprised by the overall low score of this restaurant. I've been here twice and have always had a lovely traditional Italian meal. Apart..."
Miki Glat
"Absolutely loved the pizza and pasta! Friends ordered mains and they also really enjoyed it. Service was brilliant and drinks list even better! So..."
Melbourne Food Blogger
"My partner and I visited basillico last Friday in Carnegie and had a great experience. The servers were very nice and offered their opinions on..."
Nicole
"Really like this place. Dined in tonight but I usually get takeaway and I wish I came here more often. Service was great and staff are friendly and..."
EL
"One of my absolute fav restaurants! The service is not just attentive but with a friendly attitude nothing is a problem. The food is always..."
Jonesyk12345
"The aromatic smell of fresh herbs and spices hits you as you enter through the doorway. The food is tasty.. and the homemade Gnocchi Matriciana is..."
Droidster
"Busy and enjoyable. We were a group of six and we were seated at our reserved table quickly. I had the chicken cacciatore which came with a lovely..."
Braham
"Restaurant is modern although a little noisy. Pizzas use fresh ingredients and cooked well in stone oven. Staff very friendly. Tip - You can..."
Darren Lutchner
"Food was delicious, the place is nice and modern. We went out for after work dinner. The food came a little bit to quick and you feels a little bit..."
T.v.L
"Tried Basilico For the second time last night. I must say we had a great experience both times. We walked in without a booking hoping to get in and..."
Paul
"Went to Basilico for dessert and my friend and I ordered the belgian chocolate and strawberry dessert with vanilla icecream. It was rich, decadent,..."
Biggiechee
"4 of us arrived here as a family early without a booking but was welcomed and offered a table with no problem. As the night went on the restaurant..."
Kerrie Smith
"Visited Basilico on Koornang Road, I was really impressed with the selection of food on the menu. Their wood fired pizza is just delicious, packed..."
Koli Loko
"First visit to Basilico last night and I must say it prompt me to write my first review. Made a booking with some friends and I really enjoyed this..."
Max
"We liked this place. The rating is not so great, however we think it is more a 3.5. The Pizza is fresh and very hot. The chocolate and strawberry..."
Brent Morgan
"Excellent family restaurant, probably one of the more fancy ones in koornang road. Delicious pasta pizza and steak, good wine list and lovely staff..."
SouthSideBrunch
"Just moved into the area and glad we chose this place for a feed. Friendly service and great pizza. We were a group of four and shared the chocolate..."
SK
"One word delicious! Had the chicken risotto and was to die for (fresh basil on top was the perfect finishing touch) and others had pizzas which I..."
Nina
"We frequent the Albert Park restaurant which has always been fantastic and we thought to come into the Carnegie one for dinner. Staff were attentive..."
Steve Demos
"Second visit: 12/03/2015Pizzas (Ortolana and Tandoori Chicken) not as good as before, risotto pretty average, Caesar salad was good as per the..."
TravellingFoodie
"Been looking forward for this one to open after being to their chapel st shop a few times, went there a couple days ago and loved it! Their homemade..."
Shimi Zaguri
"Great place.. I'm a local and this is what the area needs. Been here twice now and the food is amazing. Really enjoyed the lasagne and also the..."
Greg G
"Very enjoyable experience. Despite the large open space, the restaurant was warm and inviting. The portion sizes were large whilst maintaining the..."
Tania Hayes
"Food is great, chef is amazing! I wanted to customize my order a bit and he gladly did so for me. Was delicious! My partner ordered vegetarian..."
Sharni M
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes