Review Bay Pizza - North Sydney

Just ordered the Super Margarita and the El Rancho, best pizzas I’ve had in a long time, nice thin base on margarita and the El Rancho was super delicious, ordered the family size in both biggest most generous pizzas for the money I have had, rang ahead to pickup and 20 minutes just as they said were ready and fresh, Definitely my new pizza place , awesome!!!!

Absolute legends. Ordered cappriciosa via menulog, asked them in the comments to sub out capsicum and add anchovies, they did the job. Delicious thin crust pizza.

Made an order for the first time tonight and was pleasantly surprised. The best pizzas we have had in a very long time. The gentleman who gave me my order did say to me that I would be very happy with my pizzas today and I truly was! Highly recommend!

After ordering, I got a call from qld 20 mins later saying it'd be ready in another 20 minutes. The pizza was tasteless, the toppings were entirely separate to the base. Also got lasagne, which was recooked and super salty. Is this place a front for something?

Great pizza with generous toppings, very friendly and efficient service and at a decent price. It's our local pizza place and highly recommend. Thanks Simon for getting it right for us every single time - Love your pizzas. Recommend the Super Supreme!

Can echo the sentiments of reviewers below about quick & friendly service and generous toppings. But this is old-fashioned 1970's "retro" pizza. It's tasty with a thin base and brings back memories of childhood takeaway. (they still offer cabanossi!) But it's neither wood fired nor New York style, just so you know.

This pizza has all the makings of a great pizza, but a big disappointment. The crust was tasteless and not wood fired:gourmet. I won’t order from here again. The pizza was also drowned in sauce, no subtle art. From the sound of this guy he isn’t Italian, but had a Middle Eastern accent so maybe that’s a sign that it’s not authentic Italian way of pizza.

pizzas taste like the ones you’d find in a country town. There are better options out there