Review Coffin Sally - Port Fairy

9-5 Unchained

Grabbed two pizza's the pig one and the potato one. Very tasty, not skimpy on topping but not overdone either. Very thin but delightful base. Shopfront service. Really great experience and would recommend anyone who enjoys pizza to try Coffin Sally. I'll be back again for sure.

Stan Veloutsos

The pizzas were very..very..delicious, although the prawn pizza didn't have many prawns on it... The base and pizza sauces were spot on. The menu would benefit from having some thick cut potatoes with rosemary and rock salt. The staff could have also been a little more welcoming and warm. The decor is really cool throughout.

Grant Holtes

Fantastic experience - the mushroom pizza was delicious and bar by the fire was great on a cold evening.

Jurgen Hein

Great location for some tasty pizza and drinks.

Barry P

If you’ve got a hankering for a fantastic pizza made, and served, by people who have a great life attitude then head to Coffin Sally. Takeaway is via the front door during covid times. get yourself a Margherita, thin crust, perfectly cooked with a crisp base but with that cheesy chewiness full of tomato flavour, fantastic value for $14 washed down with a wicked selection of canned cocktails and beers. You won’t be disappointed. A must try in Port Fairy

Tom “Tom” Atkins

Very impressed, this cosy little place packs a giant flavour punch! Pizzas were delicious and there was a great vibe, open fire, beautifully decorated and overall warm and inviting interior. Despite being booked out, the wait staff were very lovely and accommodating. I was seated at the bar and was still very pleased with the food, drinks and attentive service. Highly recommend this place!

Stephan Klatt

It's often very hard for me to find a pizza place which has a gluten free alternative. They have it, and it's really yummy. The standard dough is also very good, and the topping is soo damn delicious. We love this place and can recommend it. We were lucky to get a table as normally you have to book in advance. So please book in advance not to get disappointed. The cocktails are also delicious. The ambiente is cool and everything comes together. Make a stop here when travelling the Great Ocean Road.

Michelle Jephcott

Booked out, but the guy on the phone suggested we do a walk up and maybe sit outside, which we did. A bit cold, but the pizza made up for it. Great pizza, wine and staff.