Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Rye

6 restaurant menus in Australia, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Del Posto 2409
Del Posto 2409
88/100 (957 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Mediterranean
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Mediterranean
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Octopus
Lasagne
Croquettes
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Crab
Fish
Scallops
Pork
Duck
Ragu
Risotto
Agnolotti
Mussels
Buffalo mozzarella
Tiramisu
Beef
Italian
Mediterranean
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Ordered a couple of the pastas including the lamb pasta. Was very impressed with the presentation, service and quality of the food. Finally a lamb..."
Mandy
"What a charming little space , very cute and staff friendly . I will say the menu is not the largest I’ve ever seen but with that comes the..."
Nikki
"Del Posto is outstanding. The bistro was strongly recommended to us by a close friend who visits this area often and knows good food and wine. How..."
Two Sheds
"Amazing food and customer service!!!Fantastic experience. One of the best italian cuisines wr have ever had! :) highly recommend!Definitely..."
Nin
"Visited tonight for our anniversary dinner - 2 adults and 3 kids. The service was faultless - our waiter went through the specials of the day and..."
Thomai Fischbacher
"We were staying locally and noticed Del Posto was open a bit later than your average dinner time with a stack of patrons enjoying a mean. Lots of..."
Steve Rakic
"I can't recommend this place highly enough. The food is fresh, delicious and fast. The wine list is good, and not over priced. Service was exellent..."
Robert.powney
"Was heading to Mornington Hot Spring and found this place not too far from it. Everything was so perfect. Service was so nice from the..."
Eating Away Melbourne
"Absolute ripper restaurant, sensational food and great service. This is without doubt The best restaurant in Rye and one of the best on the..."
Denny Patron
"SCALLOPS!!! By far the best I’ve eaten before. This is by a country mile the best place to have dinner in Rye and probably from Rosebud to..."
Birdman
"Amazing! This was the best meal my friends and I have had in ages. For $65 each we had an appetizer to share, a pasta, two sides to share, a drink..."
Laura Beckett
"Fine dining in downtown Rye. One of, if not the best in town. $$$ but worth it. Good selection of local and Italian..."
Matthew Cole
"After reading other reviews, I had high expectations when visiting Del Posto 2409. This place lived up to its reputation! The staff were attentive,..."
Amanda Farquhar
"WOW - Stunning food, in a comfortable, welcoming environment. Nick + his team were so hospitable, and the food speaks for itself. Hands down the best..."
Michael Ahmadzadeh
"So let's start off with saying best pasta I have ever had (Papadelle) Highly recommended! Place is small but has excellent service it has a wide..."
Luke Gray-Matrenza
"Dinner last night was so amazing. Restaurant was bustling but still cosy and intimate. Food was spectacular. Traditional Italian fare prepared and..."
Kelly
"Had dinner there on 2 nights while in Rye. Really enjoyable busy place. Food very good and the wines excellent. Owner and staff helpful and..."
Pat Higgins
"Meal, wine and service were amazing. Serves were a decent size. Would have loved dessert but couldn't finish my main after appetisers. Will..."
Mandy Beaton
Indulge By The Bay
Indulge By The Bay
87/100 (117 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Mediterranean
Bar
Cafe
Healthy
Australian
Bar
Pub
Breakfast
Lunch
Café
Healthy
Mediterranean
Australian
Bar
Pub
Café
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Credit Cards
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"Friendly customer service (so welcoming), generous portions (how good!!) and lovely food! Definitely will be back again if we ever visit rye again...."
Shermaine Goh
"Had the big Breakfast here and it was just amazing two pieces thick fresh toast , homemade beans , tomato, spinach , bacon, mushrooms and two eggs..."
Amanda Daw
"Haven't finished eating, but it can't wait writing review. Yes, this is how good the place is! Very good coffee, food is impeccable (very crispy..."
Chenhan Xu
"nice view,nice food,friendly staff,everything was just..."
Meng Gao
"We absolutely love Indulge Bar and Restaurant. Not only is the food amazing the staff are the incredibly welcoming always with a huge smile on their..."
debra whiteway
"This place is one of, if not the best cafe’s in Rye. Great service, great cleanliness, value for money, and fantastic food! They have a range of..."
S L
"We have now made this wonderful little gem our regular for coffee, brekky and lunch, such beautiful people, and man oh man can this man cook up a..."
Darren griffiths
"Amazing food !! Magical coffee ☕ Friendly and Happy staff, love the shirts SMILE ❤ If you are in Rye this is a must..."
Fran Shaw
Sisco Pizza Restaurant
Sisco Pizza Restaurant
86/100 (1983 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Lasagne
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Street Parking
Reservations
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"Normally get take away pizza which is fantastic, easily the best down the peninsula. Decided to eat in and see how the main menu would hold up...."
Deadset888
"We had no reservation during peak season, two adults, two kids and a pram and they still made room for us and all with a smile. Pizza was great (bar..."
Nasser
"Recommended to dine here while on holiday. Absolutely did not disappoint! Sat outside due to inside being full but were provided blankets to keep us..."
Cameron Hill
"Seafood fresh every 2 days...."
Jess Vas
"4.2To start, I have a difficult fiancé, she has that many intolerances it’s not even funny, so the fact we could order a seafood pasta..."
Jonathan Voulgaris
"The food and service was excellent. The restaurant was fully booked out on Easter Sunday but the staff came up with a creative option to accommodate..."
Yummy Tummy
"Thank you for an amazing family friendly experience. Lovely food, brilliant pasta, great local wine and crayons for kids! Even take away gluten free..."
Hare
Xpress Gourmet Pizza
70/100 (469 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Fast food
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Mid-range
Pep's Beachfront Cafe And Cucina
Pep's Beachfront Cafe And Cucina
70/100 (430 ratings)
Restaurants
Israeli
Pizza
Italian
Israeli
Pizza
Italian
Israelí
Mid-range
"Wow, the food was amazing here. Very happy, next time I am down I would like to try there pizza! The place was nice and clean, could not complain at..."
Mitch Nikolov
"tasty Italian pizzas and excellent service. The pizza bases were very thin and the toppings were just enough. Not too much not too little. We both..."
czajniow 2013
"Great food and a wonderful atmosphere. We live in Dromana but happened to drive past this restaurant one weekend and decided to go back and try it -..."
Rob Bruce