Reviews Pizza Autentico - Surry Hills

Facebook
Matěj Pluhovský
+5
If you have the same problem like me, that one pizza is never enough.. Go to this place and try at least 1 piece of every pizza.. I failed half way through! And it's soo good... Hidden gem of Sydney's pizza scene! As authentic as this place is tho, be ready for some proper banter as the manager there is a English lad with a good sense of humour. Also my girlfriend eats there quite frequently and still didn't get fat so that's a plus..
Facebook
Chris Brown
+5
One of the best pizza restaurants I have been to!! The amazing quality of the pizza was only surpassed by the friendly staff and excellent service. Would definitely recommend
Facebook
Rebecca Hickey
+5
Jonny and co have created a beautiful Italian experience in the middle of the city. This vibrant, friendly, cosy little restaurant is our local...delicious pizza and pasta ( the 4 cheese gnocchi is just the best!), a wine list that matches the food perfectly and their in house negroni is real treat! Best to book but if you get there early enough, they will always try and squeeze you in. A dining experience not to missed and one that we enjoy with family and friends often!
Facebook
Jordan Page
+5
Not only is this one of the best pizza joints I’ve ever eaten in (and I’m from New York I might add) but the the service is absolutely second to none. What an absolute hidden gem and I cannot wait to go back for more!
Facebook
Jimmy Fisher
+5
What a great place this is! Great food great service great concept. A must visit restaurant for anyone in Sydney.
Facebook
Paddy Hughes
+5
Excellent experience! Had a lot of fun here, the host and wait staff were very accommodating to our large group and helped make the night very enjoyable. The food was amazing and there was plenty of it, can’t recommend the all you can eat style enough. Great way to start the night out!
Facebook
Langley Ammit
+5
I’ve been many times with a bunch of friends, the staff are always lovely and accomodating towards us, and to everyone else there. The quality of the food has been outstanding every time, and very affordable. Would highly recommend and will continue to go back.
Facebook
Brendan Donahue
+5
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. It’s a great concept of getting different slices to sample as well.
Facebook
Matt McCormick
+5
Absolutely fantastic atmosphere! The owners, waiters, chefs made my group of friends feel incredibly welcome, and appreciated. The service was friendly, attentive, and provided with no such delay on bringing out food. I cannot rate this place highly enough for any special occasion, as the entire crew at Pizza Authentico will genuinely make it feel like an incredibly special experience. Cheers guys!
Facebook
Matt Selby
+5
Unbelievable food, fantastic service from all the staff! I would highly recommend Pizza Autentico, I can't wait to go back! Keep up the great work guys.
Facebook
Jackie Pemberton
+5
Went here for dinner last night - will definitely be back! The staff were so so so accommodating! And the food was delicious! Was full at the end and turned away a few dishes (because I was full- they looked yum!) great concept, will definitely be back.
Facebook
Matthew Boyd
+5
Both the food and the service are consistently high quality and the all-you-can-eat menu option makes the experience very affordable; will be back whenever I’m in surry hills!
Facebook
Iain Sandler
+5
Awesome service and great food, table of rude arseheads next to us were the only down point of the night, just goes to prove that you can’t polish turds! Great work pizza authentico!
Facebook
Richard Poll
+5
A really nice, refreshing approach to serving pizza and pasta. Great food, friendly service, this place is a little gem.
Zomato
Marianna Tuccia
+4
I was a bit sceptical about ‘all you can eat pizza and pasta for $25’ but I was proved wrong. It’s fun and the food is actually good. The pasta is cooked al dente and the pizza bases are thin and crispy. I thought there were plenty of choices and it’s the perfect for a cheap night out. #pizzaautentico
7 months ago
Zomato
Dashmit Aurora
+5
Went here with bunch of freinds and we all really enjoyed it. This is a special type of Italian place where they bring bunch of pastas and pizza to your table to eat for 90 min all you van eat. The server was friendly and explained patiently all the dishes which they kept bringing in from the kitchen. Will surely visit again.
Jul 23, 2019
Zomato
Josie
+5
$25 all you can eat pizza and pasta! The way this cute joint works is that servers walk around the table with pizza and pasta with time in between. The way the table is set up feels like one massive family dinner (even though everyones a stranger!) highly worth a visit
Jul 02, 2019
Zomato
Stacey Amber
+5
I don't review much but thoroughly enjoyed my experience here! Amazing food and awesome concept. I recommend everyone to come and try this place out I'd your a lover of Italian food. So cool because you can try abit of everything. Too bad I live in NZ!
Jun 20, 2019
Zomato
Nikki Shah
+4
We were in Sydney for the weekend and found Pizza Authentico as it was close to our accommodation. Hadn't been to an Italian restaurant with this concept before and loved it. Great pizzas, more like the traditional Italian style we've had in Italy, with delicious toppings. The pastas were fresh with yummy sauces, the four fromaggio gnocchi was so creamy! The food kept coming and all served by friendly helpful staff. Will definitely come back next time we are in Sydney.
Jun 17, 2019
Zomato
Ritika Arora
+4
Loved the cheesy pizzas. Great food and great service. Well cooked pizzas with a good crust. A good place for some good italian food.  In desserts, Tiramisu is my all time favorite.
Apr 19, 2019
Zomato
Maria Liuzzi-Scalpelli
+4
Great concept. Friendly staff. Great pizza with loads of variety. Pasta was good too but would have liked it more if it were homemade. The Sicilian sangria was absolutely delicious! Great flavours! My only criticism was of the espresso at the end... if you have a great Italian meal, you always need to end it with a great Italian coffee. You should invest in some nice espresso cups and better coffee. Also... tiramisù was great but the added cream was not necessary. Overall a Great experience! Well done!
Jan 15, 2019
Zomato
Baz Juan Pablo Sanchez
+4
Great concept that is sure to win over a lot of people, $20 all you can eat Pasta and Pizza is like a dream come true for some. The catch ?, you don’t choose what come out and basically are at the mercy of a rotation system. But for me that’s brilliant as it forces you try new flavors you normally wouldn’t
Nov 24, 2018
Zomato
JZ
+5
To give you a sense of my obsession, I came here on a Friday night from a friend's recommendation, and immediately came back the Friday night after. 
Situated in an alley that is slightly off the main road, this place is quite unassuming on the outside. However, once you step in, you can't help but feel the animated and bustling atmosphere, with people enjoying their meals around a large, communal table, even if it was just 30 minutes before its kitchen closes. The best part, of course, was the $25 all you can eat deal. Maybe it's just me, but I have never had pizza & pasta served in this Brazilian steakhouse manner - what a brilliant idea. Everything should be served this way. The servers came out with different pizzas and pasta every 2-3 minutes, and we got to try so many flavors, including: 
Pizzas (thin crust, bless):
1. Zucchini & Cherry Tomato: 4/5. The zucchini gave the pizza a refreshing touch
2. Spinach & Ricotta: 5/5. My favorite - the spinach was really flavorful and complimented the dough
2. Eggplant: 3/5. The pizza had a strong eggplant flavor but unfortunately I'm not a huge eggplant fan
Pasta:
1. Formaggio gnocchi: 3/5. Too cheesy in my opinion
2. Mushroom farfalle: 3/5. I normally don't like farfalle, and I thought the cheese really overpowered the mushrooms
3. Pesto linguine: 4.5/5. My favorite pasta, it was a little greasy but really tasty
As I am a pescatarian, I wasn't able to try all the flavors, which really is a blessing in disguise in this situation. i would say pace yourself so you can get at least a second serving of your favorite ones! The server was also really attentive and remembered all our dietary restrictions, and paid special attention to us when serving vegetarian options. 
Overall warm and fun ambiance, great service, satisfying food, at a really affordable price.
Oct 28, 2018
Zomato
Alison Read
+4
It was a chilly Friday night when we arrived to try this word of mouth restaurant. We were seated and given water and a drinks list. After letting them know we don’t eat meat they take our drinks order and the food begins to come out. A disc on the table alerts servers as to wether you are hungry, want to slow down or are finished. Pizzas are on my favourite base - thin and crisp- have never enjoyed the soggy style. We enjoyed a zucchini and potato, Margherita, eggplant, and ricotta and pesto .. the pastas were also amazing. There was a gnocchi with cheese sauce, mushroom and spirals, linguine with pesto and more... so full! There is cheese as well as dried chilli on the table. It is only one communal table which keeps the night lively and fun. The Prosecco was so good that I had a couple of glasses. Friendly service and a set price.
Oct 28, 2018
Zomato
The Next Rush
+4
Seated at a communal table, you're served by the owner himself. You're given a color coded hockey puck that you turn over (Green for Yes, Red for No) as the random selection from their menu begins swirling around the table. The pace is good, it doesn't feel rushed, the menu offered doesn't seem watered down and you're given a good selection and sometimes, seconds as they distribute their random curation of the night. It's great fun! Full of surprises as Lisa comes out from the kitchen.  

I like a bit of fire, particular from the Southern region of Italy, so the ARRABIATA PENNE was the perfect opener to warm up the pallette. A sauce of garlic, tomato and red chilli – loved everything about this! In between our pasta dishes, they weaved in their HAM & PEA, MARGHERITA, FOUR CHEESE, MUSHROOM pizzas. The crispiness in the bases stood out here. Such simple ingredients to make the dough but that precision in your base takes a lot of care and technique long before you have come in and ordered your pizza! Thanks Chef! 

The SPICY SAUSAGE & PEPPERS and the ROCKET & PROSCUITTO were my favorites for the evening, nice balance between toppuing and base and really good quality cheese. In terms of pasta, the FOUR CHEESE GNOCCHI came a close second to my dish of the night, it's impossible for things to go wrong here as the soft clouds of pasta bathe in a gooey fusion of cheese! I had to have seconds!  

People I know who have been hear say, that even though they are stuffed from the great feast you get here, they insist on making room for dessert and you know what they are spot on! The TIRAMISU pushes all the buttons from the elements you know expect in a creamy mascarpone, chocolate dusted masterpiece – however, the extra moistening in Espresso dunking they've down through this is impeccable and a perfect showstopper to close the Pizza Autentico food story. 

Thanks so much for having me in, cute little ambience, versatile space which I can picture using in so many ways (casual dining, group functions) and service that is personal!
Aug 28, 2018
Zomato
Foodie_Besh
+4
$25 dollars 90 minutes, eat as much as you can! Need I have to say more, naaah I don't think so. The pasta dishes and the pizza dishes were all top notch with excellent taste. The drinks were really good as well, and again students like me always search for places with happy hours and this place has one 😁. Though I would suggest anyone visiting this place to book beforehand because it can be crowded and you might have to wait for a long time.
Jul 07, 2018
Zomato
Hayley
+4
We got here for a booking at 8, and the place was relatively empty. 
It kind of works like Brazilian barbecue actually, the servers go around and ask if you'd like a slice of pizza or a scoop of pasta. 
They come out with different kinds of pizza, though not as much of their pastas. The pizza is thin crust, and cheesy. They don't fill you up too quickly. My favourite is the pepperoni pizza. Their gnocchi in white sauce is also very delicious. 
I was pleasantly satisfied after the meal, and we wish to come again.

Definitely worth the price.
Jun 04, 2018
Zomato
Lien Nguyen
+4.5
Absolutely enjoyed pizza authentico! Tucked away behind the busier streets, it can be a bit tricky to find but once you do - you would have discovered a great gem! The restaurant is laid out with one big communal table so it really does feel like a feast. Pizzas and pastas are brought out fresh from the kitchen and offered to you. There was endless options, with plenty of vegetarian options aswell. The pizzas and pastas were all delicious and I can’t really pick a fav. Such bang for your buck - will definitely be visiting again in the future. I’ve already started recommending it to friends and family.
Feb 19, 2018
Zomato
Chinmay Khisty
+4
I went there with a few friends to try this innovative concept. There is this massive centre table where all the guests are seated and the food keeps rolling out.
The food was delicious and was all we could eat. I particularly liked the gnocchi. They had an interesting selection of pastas and pizzas on that day and was totally worth the money. My only reason of not giving this a full-5 is that the food was being rolled out really slowly at times which made us wait for a long time while we were hungry. Not sure if that is something that is regular or was it just that day.
Feb 13, 2018
Zomato
Ieatthings
+4.5
Really loved this concept! $25 for all you can eat pizza and pasta. Different pizzas and pastas will be brought to your table one at a time, which you may either choose to grab a bit of or pass on.

If you’re full, or need to slow down, the cylinder block (best way I can describe it) has a yellow, green, and red side which you may flip on either side to let the staff know.

The pizza and pasta quality was excellent, although I wouldn’t say it’s the best I’ve ever had. I think the compromise would be the cheap price as well as the large variety. The waiters who served us was were all extremely lovely as well, which only improved the experience we had. I’d definitely come back!
Feb 11, 2018
Zomato
Culinary Artist
+4.5
Great place to visit if you have bottomless belly for all you can eat pizza and pasta for $25 in 90 minutes given time.
I am not joking when i said that, those savory pizza and pasta is keep coming and the funny thing is waitress that served us giving us an a funny looks when we said no to the pizza.
So many different topping and ingredients, we dine for just under 60’ and gave up. During our dinner time, there is no repeated pizza with the same topping or pasta with the same sauce that came twice to our table ( well, basically it’s a communal table ).
And we ordered also tiramisu which cost $8 extra.
Some of pasta is lack seasoning and dry, but overall food was great and awesome!
Even after we paid the bill, there was braciola, mascarpone, rocket and truffle oil pizza topping, that smells so good, the same waitress who served us said, “last piece before you hit the road?” 😁
Hahaha..



Feb 07, 2018
Zomato
Cool Beans Life
+4.5
Isha and I are absolutely obsessed with Italian food, the bold flavours and the passion with which it is cooked is captivating. The only drawback to eating it at a restaurant is narrowing down exactly what you want to eat!. Fortunately, this problem was solved when were invited to Pizza Autentico by Ompty Media. Matty, the manager, greeted us at the front door and seated us on a long  concrete island bench where he explained the elegant concept of the restaurant. For $25 per person, you can gorge yourself on as much Italian food as you want over 90 minutes. The food is circled around and you can indicate whether you want more using a neat little token which has the italian tricolours, green for more, white for pause and red for you are stuffed.
Feb 11, 2018
Zomato
Famishedduo
+4.5
All you can eat pizza 🍕🍕and pasta🍝🍝 for $25! 😍😍 Pizza Autentico has a huge variety of pizzas and pasta for your hearts content!
As soon as we were seating at the long communal table, we felt right at home.
The pizza & pasta came out one after the other and created a perfect transition from one pizza to the next. The fabulous thin crispy base and crust gives you more tummy room which you’ll definitely need because there is SO MANY flavours of pizza and pastas to try from! Not forgetting the salad selection. We had the burrata which was refreshing and creamy.
Jan 20, 2018
Zomato
Alexandra | Lalan_eats
+4
Definitely a great deal with $25 for 90mins! They bring out quite a good range of food and pretty frequently too. The shared table idea is great and maybe they should introduce some aspect of it where everyone has to interact with eachother more. 

The little circle which has two sides (red & green) are to stop or go with the food, if you turn it on it’s side it means you are slowing down! But do not fear the lovely waitress will still offer you all the food if you’re going slow!


I would describe the food as homemade (something you'd eat at home) for some people this may be amazing to have a home cooked meal served to you without the work, for others they might expect something a bit more special. But for all you can eat the food goes pretty good.  You will definitely get full off of all that pizza and pasta!  Order the 'Buratta Salad' it was my favourite dish of the night!!!

Thanks to the boys @ompty.media for the invite :)
Jan 03, 2018
Zomato
Food Queens Of Sydney
+5
This was an incredible experience!
The cute restaurant is tucked away in the back streets of Surry Hills.
The service was extremely friendly and the vibe was elegant and relaxed.
We were shocked at all the food offered to us in the all you can eat style, for only $25! The quality of the food was just delicious.
Highly recommend this fun night out!
Dec 16, 2017
Zomato
Elle Fitzpatrick
+4.5
Such a great experience! Really different from the usual dining experience because of the unique concept used. Plenty of pizza and pasta came around that we had to slow it down at the end. Nice food, friendly service and very good value for money
Dec 10, 2017
Zomato
Lollieats
+5
Oh how I loved this place. Amazing concept, $25 all you can eat but it comes fresh and oh so tasty. One of the best Pizzas I have tasted and the variety was mind blowing. The pastas were delicious too. Treat yourself to the Tiramisu as it was well worth it .
Oct 18, 2017
Zomato
The Naked Food Addict
+4.5
Had such a great experience at pizza autenico!! From the outstanding service to the scrumptious ALL YOU CAN EAT pizza & pasta and the fantastic atmosphere, I can definitely say I would recommend them! I went for an invite last night thanks to ompty and I absolutely loved it! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by Jonny (the owner) and he was so lovely! We were seated, offered drinks, and he recommended the burratta salad which had creamy burratta with tomato, basil, olive oil and balsamic. Like I always say.... "I don't make friends with salad" ... BUT i'm pretty sure this salad became my new all time favourite. The burratta cheese was BEAUTIFUL! So creamy and perfect!!

We got to try so many different pizza's and pastas! They were all great- so fresh and full of flavour! My personal favourites were the "pepperoni pizza" (tomato sauce, mozzarella fiordilatte and spicy salami), the "Quattro stagioni" pizza (tomato sauce, mozzarella, fiordilatte, prosciutto, artichokes, mushrooms and olives), "the fiessese" (tomato sauce, mozzarella fiordilatte, italian sausage, mascarpone, rocket and truffle oil), the "farfalle alla montanara" (funghi trifolati in a creamy sauce- MY ABSOLUTE FAV DISH OF THE NIGHT), and the "gnocchi formaggiosi" (creamy sauce with gorgonzola, parmesan and pecorino).

If that list alone was just my "personal favourites" you can only imagine how many we actually got to try!! It was insane!! So flipping good!! Jonny was onto everyones drinks... no one had to wait for drinks to be refilled. It was great.

The concept of this restaurant is brilliant! When you walk in, it is one big group table and you all sit around it, and you have tokens that have a green side for "go" so you are signalling you want MORE food, a red side for "stop" signalling you are done and then if you flip the token on it's side, it means "slow down".

It is definitely safe to say that I definitely will be returning, and I would recommend it in a hearbeat! :)
Sep 29, 2017
Zomato
Wendy Lieu
+4
Amazing price, quantity and service! If you would like to try more kinds of pizza, try not to make a reservation but instead sit at the table downstairs. Otherwise they bring pizzas and pasta that you might not like and cannot finish.

My favourites were the zucchini and potato pizza, eggplant and ricotta orecchiette and the 4 cheese gnocchi. The pizzas are a nice thin crust as always fresh from the oven. However most of the edges are burnt but seeing as it's all you can eat, you can just wait for a fresh slice to come around! The staff were very nice and accommodating. Will definitely return!
Sep 02, 2017
Zomato
Daniel Zhang
+4.5
I always leave this place eating much more than I should, and yet i do it anyways. This place offers 90 minutes of unlimited pizza and pasta which they bring out every couple of minutes, all for a price of $20. Food is always great and atmosphere is nice too,
great if you really wanna stuff yourself with italian food
Aug 22, 2017
Zomato
Frankiieshungrytummy
+3.5
Got invited by ompty media to try this little place out.
Located in a little alley in Surry Hills, it's tucked away from the busyness of the city life.
When you walk in, the atmosphere is warm and you share a one large table with strangers who have also come to enjoy the all you can eat pizza for 20 bucks.
Yep, that's right - 20 bucks!
You're given a token which is conveniently the colours of the Italian flag in which you flip depending on how you're feeling in terms of hunger.
Green for go, give me more!, white for pause and red for stop, I'm full.
Loving the concept of this as pizza hut all you can eat used to be my absolute fave before they shut almost all of them down.
This is a great way to try all of the different things on the menu. They also have an awesome cocktail menu!
Pizza and pasta galore, who wouldn't love this place?!
But wait, don't forget to save room for dessert as the tiramisu is to die for.
Aug 02, 2017
Zomato
Love At First Bite
+4
Pizza Autentico is an Italian restaurant located in Surry Hills that is famous for their $20 Italian buffet. The premise is simple, diners sit at a communal table while a waiter will circulate the room with one dish at a time. For 90 minutes, you can join unlimited pizza and pasta from a range of 30+ pizzas and 10+ pastas and you can also order from an extensive range of drinks, salads and desserts from the menu. We love a good all you can eat so when we heard about this we decided to check it out for a casual Friday night dinner, entering with hungry bellies ready to be filled!
Jul 20, 2017
Zomato
Weekendfoodescapes
+4
Pizza Autentico is a popular venue for a reasonably priced dinner with a lot of variety! For $20 within 90 minutes, you can eat to your heart's content on pizza and pasta. Matt and I walk in the cold winter weather in hunger and seek warm refuge within Pizza Autentico. It's so lovely and cosy inside. FOR FULL photos and review, go to the blog post
Jul 11, 2017
Zomato
Does My Bomb Look Big In This
+4
We’re seated around a long communal table that’s lit down the centre. The bulk of our dining companions are aged between twenty-five and thirty-five, and from the conversation, many are post-grads in entry-level positions in accountancy firms. Even if you choose not to talk to anyone else, eating at Pizza Autentico feels convivial on a cold, wintery Tuesday night. Over a floral Monte-Mule ($16.50) with Montenegro Liqueur balanced by ginger ale and lime, and a cut-price Aperol Spritz ($10), we celebrate happy hour by drinking in snippets of conversation.Our host, Jonny Allen, flips our tokens to green and we’re hit by wave after wave of thin-crust pizzas.There's pepperoni, mushroom, four cheeses and spicy sausage, followed by a more unusual spinach and Parmigiano-Reggiano. The pizzas are interspersed with...
Jul 09, 2017
Zomato
Coco And Vine
+4.5
In Short: Pizza Autentico is an engaging concept, with high quality, delicious Italian fare that makes this a great night out whether you’re on your own, a couple, or group. Skip lunch and head down any night of the week!. Thanks to the Pizza Autentico team for hosting us!

You know you’re going to be off to a great start, when the first thing you’re told is ‘…don’t worry about a thing, we’ve got tonight’s selection sorted…’! Now, as food bloggers you can get used to this whole leave-it-up-to-the-restaurant-to-share-their-favourites, but at Pizza Autentico in Surry Hills, this is their whole philosophy! So, if you are a foodie FOMO like me, you won’t be missing out here.
Jun 10, 2017
Zomato
Laura Cohen
+5
I love the concept of this place! The atmosphere is cozy, warm and friendly - just like the staff! They were extremely accomodating and for that I thank you. I was unsure about how it works as it isn't as clear on the website but essentially you sit at a large communal table, and the waiters bring around bowls of pasta and plates of pizza and ask if you want some. Truly brilliant. The food is delicious - just simple classic pizzas and pastas. I loved the 'Eggplant Pasta', 'Four Cheese Gnocchi', 'Four Cheese Pizza', and 'Ricotta and Spinach' - but pretty much everything. I left feeling 10x heavier than going in! Will definitely return.
May 28, 2017
Zomato
Ann
+4
It was very lovely! The waiting team was awesome, the food was great, price reasonable! All the pizzas were thin N crispy which i loved the most! Lots of cheese, full of flavor! 90minutes for all you can eat, make sure you try as much as you can! Absolutely a pizza feast!
May 05, 2017
Zomato
Postcards From Peta
+4
I was invited to check out this place in Surry Hills, they have 2 sittings 6pm or 8pm and there is a big communal type table downstairs and some more big tables upstairs. Brazilian type churrasco style dining with the tokens given to diners to start, pause and stop the food coming. You don’t need to order the food just keeps coming, pizza and pasta galore! Even though the table is big and communal, the table is so big it’s not like you are dining WITH everyone. Perfect for families, or a group of friends. The food is great quality and plenty of it, for $20 you can’t really go wrong. I would recommend ordering the amazing burrata salad, this was out favourite and perfect to refresh in-between carbs.
Apr 30, 2017
Zomato
Eva Tang
+4
Service was friendly, food was great! The only thing that would've made our night better was if the pizza and pasta came out faster and if there was more of a pasta variety! Other than that, it was lovely! I also love how left over pizza were all saved to feed to homeless.
Apr 23, 2017
Zomato
@burgersnbikinis
+4.5
ALL YOU CAN EAT PASTA AND PIZZA!!!!! $20 for 90 minutes, I literally don't know how this place is real or how I've never been before in the 3 years it's been open. There's nothing like it in Sydney! You have to go now! Run!

Pizza Autentico is an unreal concept. There's one big communal table, you take a seat, you've got a token that you flip to green for food, white for pause and red for omg I'm going into a food coma please no more.

My friend and I were invited to try it out last night and what a wonderful night we had! Host Jonny looked after us, and the vibe is so cool sharing pizza and pasta with strangers!

Literally the next hour and a half saw a constant flow of pizza and pasta..

My favourites were the potato and zucchini pizza, the mushroom bow tie pasta and the most amazing four cheese gnocchi you will actually try and steal the bowl. In between those was a steady flow of Margherita, ham and cheese, spinach and ricotta, pepperoni, pesto linguine and so much more. In the end we had to get selective with our choices because stomach space was running out!

Buuuuut please make sure you save room for dessert! Because the most sumptuous tiramisu comes out! I'm honestly not much of a tiramisu fan, but this one changed my mind!

Love the cosy communal vibe here, the staff and so friendly, the food is amazing and what a bargain night out! There's also a great cocktail and wine list to keep you going, the peach bellinis were on point.

Thanks to the guys at Ompty for the invite, and to Jonny and staff for making sure we left with big food babies! Mission accomplished!
Apr 13, 2017
Zomato
2Foodiefrogs
+3.5
Unlimited pizza and pasta for 2 hours for $20!! Yes you have read that right. If your looking for a carb fix that is the place to go. This restaurant is not like your standard restaurant, it involves communal dinning where everyone sits on one large table and the waiters and waitresses come around and ask you if you would like a piece of pizza or a bowl of pasta.

This type of method allows you to not only engage in conversation with different people but also allows you to try different types of pizza rather than having a selection of just one or two. The service was very friendly and happy to explain what is on every pizza and in every pasta before you make a selection.

Its great value too and they have a group booking option for everyone who wants to have a party and a good time.
Apr 11, 2017
Zomato
Eatventures
+4
Pizza Autentico do an all-you-can-eat pizza night for $20! When I first found out about that, I was suspicious. Surely they had to cut some corners…. Once we tried their food and saw how it all worked though, it started to make sense. There definitely weren’t any corners cut, the Autentico boys were just smart.
Mar 28, 2017
Zomato
Helen & Michelle
+3.5
We went to Pizza Autentico in celebration of a friend's birthday and we pleased with the overall dining experience. Paying $20 per person for a pizza, pasta buffet, it was quite worth its price as there was a great selection to choose from. Whilst the pizza was mediocre and simple, we appreciated the proportions and we quite enjoyed the pastas. We recommend you to go here with definitely a group of people and share all as it will be incredibly filling!
Feb 28, 2017
Zomato
Ester Escolar
+4
We were there for the 20$ all you can eat.Pizzas were tasty and fast service.Pasta they only brought us three kinds in 1 hour and a half.They should bring more pasta. Staff were attentive.I think it would be better instead of having a big table for a lot of people to have small tables so it's more personal.
Feb 12, 2017
Zomato
Peter Osman
+4
The pizza and pasta buffet was so sick! All you can eat pasta in 90mins. Tbh I was so hungry I scoffed everything down in 30mins and I was done. 

The food is good, real good!
Jan 17, 2017
Zomato
More Than Nourishment
+4.5
Really love the concept of this place.. all you can eat pasta and pizza in 90 minutes while sitting at a long communal table. They give you a token with three different colors, green for go (give me more food), white for pause and red for stop. They bring out different pizzas and pasta during the night and offer you a slice (or even two) and small portions of pasta. It was a great way to try a range of dishes without having to commit to buying a whole pizza or pasta. The food had basic flavours but was exactly what I remember it being like when having it in Rome. The pizza bases were thin and crisp while the pasta was piping hot. Everything was freshly made. Such great value for $20. I was in a carb coma by the time we left. Disappointed that I couldn't fit in the tiramisu but it gives me a reason to come back another time. Definitely worth a try!
Dec 23, 2016
Zomato
THE TRAVELLER COUPLE
+4
UNLIMITED Pizza & Pasta for $20..... say wooooot?!?! yep..... hehehe.... this is what's great about Pizza Autentico..... Sydney is getting more and more pricey in food price but Jonny (the owner) of Pizza Autentico will turn your world of pizza & pasta upside down.... :) His restaurant is unique as the soonest you arrive, he will greet you personally and you will find yourself eating on a rectangular communal table where you will feel like eating with your whole big family....

All sort of Pizza & Pasta will keep on coming from the kitchen and you can just eat whatever you want... hahaha... how awesome! :D
If you're like me, the token on your table that looks like an Italian flag will always showing the GREEN side.... LOL.... eat til your stomach says enough, then turn your token upside down til it shows RED colour...... or if you're not certain and just needed a break or a breather before trying out his amazing Tiramisu as a dessert, turn the Token to stand and showing all three colours..... :)

We don't have a favourite dish here as all pizza & pasta are just amazing.... but we love the Tiramisu as it goes straight to the heart.... hehe... :)
Nov 26, 2016
Zomato
Emily
+5
We had an absolutely amazing time here! Jonny was incredibly helpful and arranged for our group to sit upstairs. The food was delicious, more pizza than pasta but every dish was amazing and carefully prepared. Everyone was really impressed with the quality and service, we will definitely be back!
Oct 26, 2016
Zomato
My Bondi Summer
+4.5
Stop the 'hangries' at @pizzaautentico 👍🏻 With unlimited pizza and pasta.. You'll want for nothing after!🍴🍕🍝🍷Jonny the owner is lovely too, he'll beg you to try his tiramisu👌🏻Only $20 for all you can eat, just a short stroll down Brisbane Street😉 @mybondisummer #mybondisummer
Oct 13, 2016
Zomato
Mara Pitton
+5
Great service and very well done pizzas. Was impressed by the good customer service and the great tastes that came from this place. Will return.
Oct 01, 2016
Zomato
Coffeebrunchanddinner
+4.5
Pizza Authentico is the place you come to when you are craving fresh pizza and hot pasta. At a standard $20 all you can eat we encourage you to bring an appetite with you. Pull up a chair at the communal table as you walk in and wait for the delicious food to be served to you. The decor is authentic, well placed and stylish and this restaurant is not your typical all you can eat. This place caters to all people eating out. For those who are in a group there is plenty of space, those flying solo will be looked after and feel part of the group. This would also be a perfect little spot for those first couple of dates or to revisit date night with your partner.

You will have your own oil, cheese and chilli at your disposal and the alternating pizza and pasta dishes just keep coming as long as your token is turned to green. If you are done flip it to red. Not sure if you have finished? Place it middle side up and take a break while you digest and make room for more deliciousness. On our visit we managed to try 6 different pizzas and countless pastas - the pesto, spicy tomato and creamy mushroom were standouts. We loved the tomato and basil pizza as well as the potato and zucchini. Drinks wise the $6 happy hour for prosecco, beer and vino and $10 spritz are great value as well. If you have a larger group of people book a spot at the smaller group tables upstairs - with its own bar section and food delivered to your table this is an awesome area of the restaurant.

Pizza Authentico is in a great spot being only a 5 minute walk from Museum Station. If you are driving nabbing a park on the street can be tricky, however, there is a Wilson car park on Goulburn street that will only cost you $10 after 5pm!

Come for the all you can eat any night of the week and if you can fit in dessert go for the Nutella pizza (grab takeaway for breakfast if you have to)! This will definitely feature on our list of places to visit again.
Sep 27, 2016
Zomato
Food Is Really Great
+4
I saw this place come up on my zomato feed and as soon as I read "$20 for 90 minutes of all you can eat pizza and pasta" I knew this was the place for me. The staff are so friendly and casual, it was a super fun experience. The pizzas are thin crust which is great because that saves space for the pastas too! The 'stop, pause, go' tokens are a fantastic idea and at first my group was determined not to pause at all, but the pizzas and pastas just kept coming .... you're not obliged to eat every pizza and pasta that comes around (my vegetarian friend skipped the meat ones but on that note like 70% of the options are vegetarian), but it's worth a try! One thing that's more my personal taste though is the abundance of gorgonzola cheese on a lot of the dishes, which got kinda intense after a while, but that being said - if you love all cheeses and all pizzas and all pastas, then this is your chance to try them all!!
Sep 24, 2016
Zomato
Josh Bryer
+4.5
The best. Prompt, tasty, affordable. By far one of the best authentic Italians in the Eastern Suburbs. Good on the mouth, without paying through the nose. Recommend highly.
Sep 10, 2016
Zomato
Eatwithmyfoodsafari
+4.5
Located just off Oxford Street near Museum Station, this lovely 2 story restaurant is a hidden gem.

We had dined here a couple of times, once as guests of the restaurant and Ompty and as regular customers as we loved it so much.

They offer a very good value all you can eat offer for $20. This allows you 90 minutes of an unlimited selection of pizzas and pastas. They are of very good quality and the menu will rotate depending on the night you go on so you may have to visit a few times to try their whole menu! It is like Churrasco style of dining where you have the green/red button in front of you and you have green for good to go for food and red for no more please!

The service is quite attentive and extremely friendly. They serve you individual slices from whole pizzas they bring out as well as dishing out individual portions of pasta from the big bowls they have.

The highlights were the Gnocchi Quattro Formaggi which were like little pillows of potato goodness covered in a delicious flavoursome cheese sauce, Spinache e Ricotta Pizza had a good ratio of spinach and ricotta and was very tasty, Margherita Pizza was a simple affair of tomatoes and cheese but oh so yummy on their thin crust base, and Tiramisu ($8) is worth paying extra for as it was one of the nicest ones I have had in a long time and probably the highlight which was amazing considering it is a pizza and pasta restaurant.

The Basil & Pine Nut Pesto Linguine was hit and miss. One night it lacked the punch of a regular pesto and slightly oily whereas the other other night it was flavoursome and on point. The Quattro Stagioni Pizza was also a bit soggy as there were too many ingredients on it. Guess the simpler the better applies here.

Overall it would be a great night out for family and friends and very well priced for the city. Definitely wear your stretchy pants as you'll need them if you wish to try the enticing range they have. It is a lovely spot and wouldn't hesitate to dine here again.
Sep 02, 2016
Zomato
Erika-Anne
+4
Superb!
Only $20 for 90min All you can eat unlimited Pizza, pasta, gnocchi and pizza.

It's hard to believe that able to eat good food just for $20 plus unlimited! But It's possible at Autentico:)

I have more than 5 kinds of pizza, 3 different pasta for that night. I was so full but delicious food didn't let me stop eating!haha

Staff were keep on serving us fresh and delicious food. I'm so satisfied.
My favorite food is bolognése and cheese pizza.
Better try them!!!

They do really delicious cocktails too.
We had tiramisu for dessert which just cost $8 and the portion was large and soooo delicious. I ate it all.

The ambience is chilled and relaxed, serving was quite quick and the staff were friendly.
I defs come back.

It's located near Museum station. Just few min walk.


Aug 28, 2016
Zomato
Spooning Australia
+3.5
PIZZA AUTENTICO is a progressive all you can eat Italian Pizza and Pasta restaurant in Surry Hills. The lovely gents from Ompty took myself and the lovely Nat from @getfatwithnat to dinner at this remarkable local.


The concept is a simple and fun one, one embraced by most Brazilian meat venus. For 90 minutes, enjoy unlimited pizza and pasta from their range of 30+ pizzas and 10+ pastas for $20 per person. You get a colour disc on your table per person. Green means go as in keep bringing me food and Red is stop. There was a pause option but for the life of me I can’t remember but you can pause for dish or two to get your breath.

Clickety Click for Full Review......
Aug 28, 2016
Zomato
2hungryysisters
+4
A formal invitation was sent to me by a friend to inform us by the owner of this beautiful restaurant to dine here. The moment we walked in, the place had a beautiful aesthetic, as well as kind staff who immediately greeted us and showed us a great amount of hospitality. They have an amazing deal where its all you can eat pizzas and pastas for a whole 90 mins at only $20 per person. This generous deal is amazing for the quality of food being served. 
We had pizzas ranging from a simple pepperoni to an amazing proscuitto, rocket and parmesan pizza. We were certainly served a lot of food. The pastas were also amazing, my favourite ones were the premium mushroom one and the basil pesto. 
We also treated ourselves with a few drinks, the Aperol sprtiz cocktail had to be the winner of everything we drank. It had a lovely citrus twist to is. 
We even indulged ourselves in the special tiramisu which was generously served to us. alongside some fresh cream and strawberries. We certainly did over eat, however, it was a great place and has amazing food for a very cheap price. 

Definitely will be returning for another amazing pizza and pasta feed!
Aug 26, 2016
Zomato
Christine
+3.5
$20 for an hour and a half of all-you-can-eat pizza and pasta is quite a steal. Set up as a massive family-style table, coming with a group can be a little stifling for good conversation, but the pizzas and pastas that are served are pretty good. Though there is quite a wide variety of toppings (on thin bases) and types of pasta and the staff are very friendly and accommodating, excess cheese and oil can make it a bit heavy.
Jul 26, 2016
Zomato
Michelle Rose Lwin
+4.5
It was really lovely and it was great value for money. I went here for an early birthday eve meal for 2 and they had a constant flow of a great variety of pizza and pasta. Ended up eating more that we really should have. Also they had a tiramisu with a sparking candle option available as a surprise for my boyfriend which was really nice and executed smoothly. All in all I definitely recommend this place for a date/special event/group dining etc. Customer service was great too.
Jun 05, 2016
Zomato
Thewhereto
+4
They say variety is the spice of life and for $20 that is what you will get at this restaurant. The concept is similar to Brazilian BBQ; indicate green you eat, indicate red and you're done or having a rest. Go nuts for 90 minutes, all you can eat. A communal table set up offers a relaxed atmosphere that would suit all occasions and would be especially good for hosting a party. The friendly staff are constantly circulating quality thin base pizza and pasta. With more than 30 gourmet pizza variants they are sure to have something to your liking. I devoured over 10 varieties of pizza a couple of pastas and salad. My fave was the pizza topped with Gorgonzola scattered with Italian pork and fennel sausage.You can wash your meal down with a range of Italian beverages birra, vino cocktails and more. When we thought we were tapped out the waiter sold us on the tiramisu, to which we are now grateful for. Like a slice of heaven, it was light fluffy and delicious. Some how we managed to fit it in. You can usually make room for a good dessert, especially one this good. A little hidden but if you find yourself dining here you will not be disappointed. Be sure to wear a pair of pants with an elastic waistline.
May 12, 2016
Zomato
Yulithefoodie
+4
All you can eat pizza for $20! Seriously what could go wrong?? Nothing!! I love their pizzas!! The star of the restaurant!! And the gnocchi omg!! How could I forget to take a picture of the gnocchi!!! Seriously guys and girls if you are after a good pizza this is the place! Plus for $20! It definitely does well for your wallet too! They are thin crispy pizza and not the thick based ones that will make you full easily! Definitely will come back for more!
May 08, 2016
Zomato
Two Girls One Fork
+4.5
We are about to tell you something that is bound to become the worst news your waistline has ever heard. Here goes.

We found... unlimited pizza and pasta. We know, we know. How can such a thing be legal?! But it very much is. And it's not sizzler!

For $20 you can tap into an hour and a half session of all you can eat pizza and pasta that is effing amazing! We only lasted twenty minutes 😱😱😜 See you at there! Oh and please try the blue cheese pizza. It will rock your world 🍕
Mar 30, 2016
Zomato
Sweetandyummie
+4.5
GO ASAP ! This place cooks up delicious pizzas and pastas that will make your mouth water and leave you trembling for more.... and why not.... its all you can eat!!! Woohoo..... Grab your besties and get seated at the massive table and eat your heart out... dont stop at one... go hard !!! The Pizzas are nice and thin with delicious toppings. The pasta is cooked al dente with great flavours on offer. Customer service is attentive and bossman Jonny will make sure you have a great time!
Mar 23, 2016
Zomato
Amys_food_adventures
+4
Why have I not know about this place?! Been in Sydney for nearly 2 years and I visit for the first time last night! The concept is easy, they bring out different types of pizza and pasta to you and you eat as much as you want and only put it on pause or stop when you have had your fill! So much fun! And a good variety of pizza form cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, parmigiana. sausage and so forth. Pasta includes pesto linguine, 4 cheese gnocchi, spaghetti etc etc. Food was delicious and so were the Aperol spritz! Great place for dinner catch ups or lunch!
Mar 23, 2016
Zomato
Katherine Pham
+4
Eat as much pizza and pasta as you can. Freshly made thin crusty pizza served by friendly staff going around a big communal table. Such a great concept as you can eat so many different types of pizza and pasta without rushing to finish before it gets cold. Will definitely come back.
Feb 01, 2016
Zomato
Lipstick On My Wine Glass
+4.5
Have no fear, first daters, and Tinder novices. The perfect place to wine and dine your Tinderella has arrived, right in Surry Hills. About a 6-10 minute walk from Museum Station in Sydney, on Brisbane street, there lies a place that you.Must.Go.To. With a $20 pp all you can eat pizza and pasta deal for dinnertimes, can you really say no?...
Jan 20, 2016
Zomato
Melissa
+3.5
This place was soo much fun and a bargain. $20 for all you can eat pizza and pasta. We came here with a group of people and we all left feeling sick as we are too much. (No one wanted to be the first to turn their wood thingo to red) The waiter who served us was nice and very attentive. Good chilled vibes and nice for something different.
Dec 02, 2015
Zomato
Sharon
+4
This place is amazing! Only $20 a head for all you can eat authentic Italian food. What more can you ask?! The food was amazing and I loved the thin bases, it really allowed you to try everything they had. They food came out really fast and the service was really good as well. A few highlights for me would be the four cheese gnocchi, prosciutto & rocket pizza and the zucchini & potato pizza but everything was perfect. I will definitely be back again!
Nov 22, 2015
Zomato
Audrey Svoboda
+3.5
Great value for money at just $29 a head for unlimited pizza, pasta and nibbles. I came here with a large group for a family dinner, and usually with family dinners its hard to please everyone.. But this place was a plus for every single person as the pizza was quite good for an all-you-can-eat place, my favourite being the Capricciosca which was a combination of ham, mushrooms, olives and anchovies. The pizza base is nice and thin how I like, and topped with reasonable amount of toppings. We were surely stuffed by the end of the night!! 

They also have a decent wine bar, so you can enjoy all-you-can-eat pizza with a bottle of Italian Red, or some Italian beer. Very impressed with this place, I would definitely recommend this place for a group dinner as its very shareable - but make sure to book ahead as the place is small and cozy.
Nov 10, 2015
Zomato
Simply Starving
+3.5
I love the concept of Pizza Autentico: One large communal table in a contemporary industrial setting, all you can eat Italian and colourful putties to let staff know when you can't fit anything else in. Tucked away on Brisbane Street in Surry Hills, I couldn't think of a better place for an intimate 18th or 21st - it's a lot of fun!

I went on a quieter night of the week, which was a big mistake as I missed out on seeing what all the fuss was about in terms of atmosphere. Luckily, the service was outstanding - our waiter was friendly and efficient, and we could not fault him!

The food was what you would expect, nothing too special due to the all you can eat nature, but still delicious! My favourite dish was the margherita pizza - an absolute classic! I'm definitely planning to return with a bigger group when there's something big to celebrate!
Oct 24, 2015
Zomato
Lawrence Wisdom
+3.5
Great idea with the red and green chip. Really enjoyable meal, and friendly staff. Would have a great at atmosphere when full. Would definitely come back with a larger group!
Oct 20, 2015
Zomato
Amr80
+4.5
It's a Favourite!!. I'm lucky enough to have Pizza Autentico located on the same street as my home and I can't praise it enough.

Upon arrival, you are seated at a communal table, which usually I feel uncomfortable with. However, as this communal table is very large, the experience ends up being quite lovely. The idea behind the menu is all-you-can eat pizza and pasta for $20 to be consumed within 90 minutes. The main thing that I love about the pizzas is they're simple, each with a beautiful thin base, yet they're packed with bags of flavour. My favourite is definitly the spinach and ricotta, however, I could quite happily name all of the varieties here. This goes for the pastas as well, they're delicious. My partner particularly enjoys the gnocchi.

As for Jonny and his team, I feel they really understand how to treat their dinners well. They've set up the service so they're personally bringing around the slices of pizza, rather than whacking a giant pizza in the middle of the communal table with the potential for it to go cold. This approach may not work for everyone, but it's something that I finds adds quality to the experience.

With this winning combination of awesome pizza and pasta linked with a value for money price and personal service, who wouldn't go back for multiple visits!!
Apr 14, 2015
Zomato
Sir And Mlady Dine Out
+4.5
It's a simple but very effective concept - $20 for unlimited pizza and pasta for two hours (or for lunches it's only $15 for an hour and a half). It's a great deal, the food was delicious and we could barely move when we left - and all the other people there were saying the same things.
Jun 23, 2014
5
Stephen B. Cohen
+5
We had an excellent dinner at Pizza Autentico last Sunday night. We were made very welcome by friendly staff who were very helpful and attentive during the night. We ordered four pizzas which were traditional style and had a great variety of contrasting flavours. From the sweet La Cabretta which included walnuts and honey, to the La Tizi which featured bresaola, mushrooms and Gorgonzola which is a very strong blue cheese. The mushrooms and Gorgonzola worked really well together, creating a wow moment. We highly recommend Pizza Autentico.
4
Joanna
+4
Had an awesome and fun night with friends because you didn’t have to worry about what to order, the kitchen just keep cooking pizza (thin base) & pasta (when you go bottomless). They will judge how much you can eat and stop bringing out things once you slow down with the food. Good for parties.
5
Coco and Vine (Coco & Vine)
+5
Pizza Autentico is an engaging concept, with high quality, delicious Italian fare that makes this a great night out whether you’re on your own, a couple, or group.Amazing value too! Skip lunch and head down any night of the week! Definitely try the tiramisu... Just like Nonna makes! A big thanks to the Pizza Autentico team for hosting us.
5
Kevin Nguyen
+5
This is actually a pretty funky place; cool concept! My tips before coming is to arrive with an empty stomach. The pizzas are thin crust and the pastas are super creamy; so to get the most value and the best pizzas try to avoid the pastas and make sure to ask the waiters/waitresses for what pizzas are available. They will bring pizzas out depending on what is being made but you do have the choice to ask from their 20 something choices of pizzas. I have attached a few photos which show just how happy everyone is with the mealie had :)
5
Paul Anderson
+5
What a fantastic lunch at this gem of place. I've been before before and always enjoyed. This time we had a good size group of friends, all seeking a fun lunch outing. For many this was their first visit. The planning and lead-up could not have been simpler (thanks Jonny). The suggested shared menu selection accommodated for all and very yum! Jonny and team very attentive, no-one left hungry, and all friends were overwhelmingly impressed. And, the Elderflower Gin Spritz was certainly a favourite!
5
Joann B
+5
I love the concept of this place - $25 for 90 minutes of endless flows of pizza and pasta. Servers come around continuously, handing out slices of pizza and small servings of pasta to everyone sitting at the large table. The mass amounts of food doesn't mean a drop of quality though - their pizzas and pastas are delicious! The pizza bases are crunchy and tasty, the toppings are amazing, and the pasta are all cooked to al dente. I HIGHLY recommend their four cheese gnocchi and four cheese pizza. Make room for these when they come around! It's a great place to catch up with mates with over some really food. We will definitely be heading back here again soon!
Clicca per espandere