I’m going through a pie phase at the moment so I’ve been having my fair share of pies but this was one of the better ones! It is on the pricier side but it was delicious. I had the truffle and chicken mushroom pie and the truffle flavour was very prominent which I enjoyed. My favourite part of pie is the pastry and this pastry was flakey and delicious as well. Will definitely be back to try other fillings and the sweet pies which look amazing! Only problem is finding parking can be quite difficult
All different flavours of pies!!! Both savoury and dessert pies!!! Surprisingly, flavours are spot on! For the dessert pies, right level of sweetness! Highly recommend the the lime whipped cream pie, I really like the tint of sourness from the lime. For the savoury pies, I do really love their beef pies! Definitely perfect when I’m craving for meat and need my iron intake.
I had heard so much about this place & finally made it. Its not a big place & just off busy King Street but it does have a huge selection of sweet & savoury items on offer. It was so hard to decide as everything looked beautiful & tempting. Apparently there are over 100 different flavours on rotation! I tried the BBQ brisket & chicken & leek pies for savoury & both were tasty. I loved the generous fillings in both. The brisket was super tender & a little on the sweet side. The chicken was creamy & I personally loved the tarragon flavour coming through. The pastry though was a bit too thick and doughy for my liking. I chose the pumpkin & key lime pies for sweets and both were delicious. Super light & fluffy filling so not overly heavy but still has rich, I adored the pumpkin pie pastry. The key lime pie has a classic cheesecake crumb base which was yummy & its very creamy. Would love to try more sweet and savoury items. Service was super friendly & helpful.
9/10
The pie tin has an amazing selection of unconventional savoury and sweet pies. Fillings taste amazing and the crusts on both the sweet and savoury pies are what makes a good and bad pie and you can see them making the pies in the back so of course the crusts were superb tasted amazing.
1) Truffle Chicken - You can see the chunks of chicken and taste the truffle but if you've never had truffle before it tastes like a chicken and mushroom pie
2) Sweet Roasted Duck - A sweet tomato based filling with chunks of tender duck inside, must get
3) Baklava Pie - Served with rosewater syrup, tasted like how you expect but in a pie
4) Lime Pie - Really creamy lime filling, wish it was a more punch in your face lime flavour but still a favourite
Best pumpkin pie I’ve ever tasted in my life ! Perfect balance. Blueberry pie was good, not sweet. my fav was pumpkin pie. Pie r great with scoop of vanilla ice cream but ice cream melts fast so I’ll ask them to put in a cup next time cuz it’s on the plate with the pie and makes the pie soggy.
Ice coffee was too bitter so I didn’t like it and didnt drink it.
Beef meat pies were good but not amazing.
Great little spot off the main street in Newtown. Huge selection of pies, both sweet and savoury. The sweet pies have perfect bases, great crunch factor without being too hard and the fillings are flavoursome without being overly sweet and unbearable. There is a huge range of savoury options with some really unique flavours, of the three I had they were overall okay, nothing remarkably special. Reasonable price for the size of the portions and a great vibe inside. Definitely check it out when in the area.
Lime pie is to DIE FOR. Best dessert pie I’ve ever tasted. Its most famous banoffee pie does not disappoint as well. Ambience is nice for some light reading or to catch up with friends.
Came here for some sweet old pie, they have sweet and savoury available with coffee and tea to accompany it.
They live up to their name and when you walk in you can see pies everywhere, as a cafe they also served light meals as well.
@asianfoodninja #asianfoodninja
cozy place, welcoming atmosphere, yet the pies are all good lookin. tried the cherry ripe, really good. ratio of crust and filling is good, not too heavy. just perfect
The Pie Tin has made me want to open my phone and review places again on Zomato. They have the best collection of savoury and sweet pies in Newtown. We had the salted caramel and malteasers pie, they were extraordinary. Each pie was heavy and should be shared. The ambience of the place is rustic, it has good service and is located few minutes away from the station. This would be in my top 10 places in Newtown list.
Great service over the phone and friendly ladies working at the shop. Best part is the beautiful, freshly made American pumpkin pie! First time trying this place out and it's been a real treat. Nice green plants inside and wide selection of sweet and savoury options. Just tried the pumpkin pie with added cream and it's divine! Lovely flavour, freshly made with a gorgeous crust. The carry container they provide is also nice with a window on both sides, so you can see the pie easily. Everyone at work loved the pie, thank you to your team! Xxx
The best pie shop with a great selection of savoury and dessert pies. They do an excellent American style pumpkin pie and I always come back here whenever I get a craving. Lots of other flavours such as Banoffi (not too sweet and lots of cream to balance the sweetness), Earl grey mousse (very light with subtle but noticeable Earl grey flavour), and Peanut butter (like a big Reese's peanut butter cup).
Hands down the best pie shop I've ever been to. Both sweet and savoury! So far I love everything I've tried and its rare that I'd come to Newtown without getting at least something from this place. Love their Whipped Lime pie but Blueberry is the bomb 🤩
![5]( "Recensione")
My new favorite pie shop at the moment.
I love everything about the pie that I’ve tried.
Delicious crunchy crust, baked to perfection,
Gourmet filling crafted for each pie, bring all the pie to next level!
I’ve tried:
“Pizza”; triple smoked diced ham, artichokes, slice olives, mozzarella and tomato sauce.
The smell is so irresistible!
Taste is really good, just like eating pizza 🍕 for sure in form of baked crunchy pastry 😀.
“Beef Brisket”; slow roasted brisket, mushroom, coffee, and maple gravy.
Can’t get more gourmet than that, right?
I do love it, however my personal opinion it touch sweet on the gravy.
It doesn’t stopping me finishing those bad boy though 😀.
“Maple Chocolate Strawberry” as a dessert was the best option.
Soft baked centered delicate Belgian chocolate brownies, garnished with maple macerated strawberry…
OMG.. it’s a happy ending!
Next one I’ll try different sweet, I’m going to try this “blended sweet pie thick shakes”, which basically a piece of sweet pie of your choice added into milkshakes…. 😋
Hasn't really changed much over the years.
Great selection of both savoury and sweet pies. The sweet ones are very indulgent and rich in flavour.
I haven't tried the coffee here, but overheard that they ran out of soy milk which was a shame for that patron. Wasn't really an issue but probably not a reliable coffee joint.
Small seating area inside, but does get busy really fast.
Good for kids (exciting for them).
Pumpkin pie was amazing, the beef and stout pie delicious and pork & fennel sausage roll splendid! The apple and Berry pie on the other hand was sad :(
Couldn't be happier with the order I placed with Pie Tin recently. The team were super friendly, were happy to answer all of my questions about dietary requirements/sizes/etc, and the two pies that were ordered were incredible! Super easy to pick up in store as well. Thanks guys :)
Done a day trip to the city today and before going home in the afternoon my family and I decided to visit the Pie tin for the first time. We were excited to try a pie. We ended up buying the Apple & Berry Pie. It looked amazing. The place looked cosy and comfortable too. But we don't know what happen to the lady that served us. The lady looked really unhappy.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Sydney
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes